Tuesday, October 13, 2026

The Man Who Knew Too Much (1956): A Review

THE MAN WHO KNEW TOO MUCH (1956)

The 1956 film The Man Who Knew Too Much as a few interesting historic footnotes. It is the only remake that director Alfred Hitchcock made of his own film (the original made in 1934). It is the last Hitchcock film to win a competitive Oscar in Best Original Song. That song's title is, according to the screen credits, Whatever Will Be, Will Be. Most of us know it as Que Sera, Sera. I think more than a few people forget that Que Sera, Sera came from a Hitchcock film. We even forget that there were two songs written for The Man Who Knew Too Much. Well-acted, with an engaging story, the second version of The Man Who Knew Too Much works quite well.

American doctor Ben McKenna (James Stewart) is on holiday in exotic Marrakesh. With him are his wife, former professional singer Jo Conway (Doris Day) and their son, Hank (Christopher Olsen). Dr. McKenna had just finished off a medical convention in Paris and was showing his family where he fought in World War II. On their way, they encounter the mysterious Louis Bernard (Daniel Gelin). Bernard has a very curious fascination with the McKennas. Ben happily gives Bernard all the information he wants. Jo notices how Bernard pumps Ben for information but never reciprocates no matter how hard she tries.

In Marrakesh, the McKennas also encounter the Edward and Lucy Drayton (Bernard Miles and Brenda de Banzie). They are a British couple also staying at their hotel. The Draytons recognize Jo from her former singing career. They help Ben and Jo by showing them around and translating what they hear in French to English. That comes in handy when the four of them, along with Hank, encounter Bernard staggering towards them. He is in brown makeup, with a knife literally in the back. Bernard whispers to Ben a shocking secret: there is to be an assassination of a head of state in London. He is told to find "Ambrose Chappell". 

What Ben is not told, at least initially, is that Hank has been abducted to keep Ben quiet. Ben is forced to drug Jo before revealing that Hank has been kidnapped by the Draytons to ensure his and Jo's cooperation. This almost completely shatters Jo. However, they are determined to both rescue their son and stop the assassination. Now, it is off to London. Jo is still a wildly popular and beloved singer in Britain. She has a circle of friends eager to reunite with her and her husband. First Ben and later Jo search for "Ambrose Chappell". Jo is the one who finds that the name is not of a person but of a place. 

Hank, however, is still being held prisoner by the duplicitous Draytons. Edward is committed, but Lucy is starting to waver, the thought of harming a child playing at her conscience. Eventually, the McKennas learn that the assassination is set to take place at the Royal Albert Hall. Will they be able to stop the killing? Will they manage to also rescue Hank?


One of The Man Who Knew Too Much's strongest element is how it keeps things grounded. Ben and Jo McKenna are not superheroes. They are ordinary, average people caught up in terrifying circumstances. It speaks well of the film that Jo is the more sensible of the two. Ben is not dumb. He is, rather, very trusting and open. Jo, for her part, is quickly suspicious about Louis and aware that her husband is being duped. A good way that Hitchcock shows the dynamic is in a restaurant scene.

James Stewart has a lot of physical comedy attempting to both sit and eat. Stewart's tall, lanky frame and struggle to eat according to the local custom shows how clumsy he is. It makes the transition to making him a more forceful figure desperate to save his son all the more impressive.

The Man Who Knew Too Much also showcases Doris Day's strengths as a dramatic actress. She displays Jo's intelligence when dealing with Bernard. Her best scene, though, is when she learns that Hank has been abducted. In his efforts to protect Jo before telling her about Hank's abduction, Ben has pushed her into taking tranquilizers. The mix between her terror at hearing of her only child's fate and the drugs lulling her to sleep create a great moment. Day is excellent throughout the film. She similarly has a strong sequence at the Storm Cloud Cantata section. She shows the immense struggle between keeping silent to save her son and saying something to save the Prime Minister. 

The other performances work almost all well. Bernard Miles shifts easily between the kindly Mr. Drayton and the villainous Mr. Drayton. He makes it believable that the same man who was so helpful to Ben and Jo would not shrink from murdering a child to protect himself. Similarly, Brenda de Banzie's evolution from being cold towards Hank to realizing the evil of killing kids is strong. I was not too keen on Daniel Gelin's Louis Bernard. He seemed to try too hard to be mysteriously charming.

Music is one of The Man Who Knew Too Much's strongest points. The film introduced what would become Doris Day's signature song, Que Sera, Sera. She sings it twice, and each time its use illustrates something about the Jo character. The first time, it plays like a nice lullaby, expressing optimism. The second, it plays like a way to release tension. The joyful lyrics and melody by Jay Livingston and Ray Evans play counter to the tension of the scene.

As stated, there are actually two songs that Livingston and Evans wrote for The Man Who Knew Too Much. It is unfortunate that We'll Love Again has been pretty much forgotten, eclipsed by Que, Sera, Sera. That is understandable, as We'll Love Again plays, almost inaudibly, when Ben is cornered by the assassin in the latter's efforts to escape. The other major piece is Arthur Benjamin's Storm Cloud Cantata, the piece of music that is meant to cover the fatal gunshot. "There came a whispered terror on the breeze", the cantata begins. Intentionally or not, the Storm Cloud Cantata fits into the story. I would say that it was intentional, as the Storm Cloud Cantata was used, per my understanding, in the original version. Here, we get to see Bernard Herrmann, who wrote the remake's score, conduct. It is a nice touch to have the film's composer (and regular Hitchcock scorer) appear on screen. 

I think that John Michael Hayes' adaptation of the original version's screenplay spent too much time on the wrong "Ambrose Chappell". The fact that there was an Ambrose Chappell Senior and Junior did not help. Neither did adding what I trust were comedic elements in the taxidermist's shop involving swordfish and tigers.

That, I think, was a misstep. Still, it was a small one. The Man Who Knew Too Much works well as a thriller that keeps things going to the end. The last bit did add a nice comic punch, which was needed after all the suspense. The future may not be ours to see, but it is well worth watching The Man Who Knew Too Much.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Views are always welcome, but I would ask that no vulgarity be used. Any posts that contain foul language or are bigoted in any way will not be posted.
Thank you.