Thursday, October 29, 2026

Clayface: A Review

CLAYFACE

Beauty may be only skin deep, but what if your skin could shift to forms beautiful and monstrous? Clayface does pretty much everything right. It has a well-crafted origin story without tying itself to a larger mythos. It has solid visual effects. It has mostly strong performances from the cast. Clayface works on many levels. 

Up-and-coming actor Matt Hagen (Tom Rhys Harries) has just received the best news possible: he's received an Academy Award nomination. Hagen has risen from the lowest rung of Gotham's ghettos to being the toast of the city. He and his BFF, Corey Bowery (Joshua James) celebrate by hitting the Vesuvius nightclub. Here, Hagen meets the beautiful Mia Torrez (Joana Riberio). Corey warns Matt that Mia is the girlfriend of ruthless mob boss Markos Szabo (David Densick). Despite this warning, Hagen goes to bed with Mia.

Poor career choice. Szabo tracks them down to Hagen's apartment the next morning. Szabo lets his mistress go, but Szabo's goons slice up Matt's pretty face in brutal fashion. Worse, Matt can't fight Szabo in court, as the mob kingpin holds major power over the courts and police. Matt finds himself out of money, out of a career and back at Gotham's slums.

An unexpected source of hope comes when Matt stumbles onto an article on Dr. Caitlyn Corr (Naomi Ackie). She's pioneering new nanotechnology that will help restore disfigurements. Corr insists that she's years away from human trials, but she's also facing financial struggles to keep her lab. With that, a measured, small trial begins. Initial results appear promising, but soon, complications make Matt's face unstable. Desperate, he injects himself with an excessive amount of the serum.

At first, it looks like the problem is not only restored but has unexpected benefits. Matt not only looks stable but heals immediately from all wounds. Corr, along with her long-term fiancée, Detective John Borelli (Max Minghella), are cautiously optimistic. Things take a turn for the worse when Matt finds that anger and stress create two separate physical effects. His face and body take on freakish shapes. His body also can take the shape of anyone he thinks of. 

Matt's physical instability is outdone by his mental instability. Enraged at seeing how his former business manager not only swindled him but works for Szabo, Matt loses control and kills him. Borelli, one of the few honest Gotham cops, wonders if Szabo is cleaning house over the Hagen case. There will be more murders and deep tragedies for those near Matt. Will Matt Hagen find peace within or unleash a monster?


Clayface has many great positives to it. First is that the story works as a pure origin story without needing to get into the larger Batman mythos. Apart from taking place in Gotham, Clayface does not involve anything else that ties it into other others. There were no in-jokes or winks to the audience in Mike Flanagan and Hossein Amini's screenplay (with story by Flanagan). To be fair, I am not so well-versed in Batman lore as to positively declare that there were no nods to Batman in Clayface. I can say that if there were, I did not notice them.

Another strong positive in Clayface is that the title character was portrayed in a sympathetic light. Matt Hagen is not a bad man. In fact, we see throughout Clayface that he is actually at heart a decent, ordinary person. Early in the film, he steps away from the hubbub of the Oscar nomination to find a quiet space. There, he breathes in the moment while softly thanking his mother, saying that this was for her. Later on, Dr. Corr sees video of Hagen talking to kids from the old neighborhood. He points out that he had a mentor who guided him into acting, and that he managed to get out of the ghetto. If he could, Matt argues, they could too. We also see that after his first killing that Matt is filled with genuine shock and remorse at his actions.

It is a credit to director James Watkins that the cast gives solid performances throughout. Tom Rhys Harries makes Matt Hagen into a fully fleshed character (no pun intended). He is sympathetic and frightening whenever the character needs to be. Harries has enough of a physical appeal to make his transformation into Gotham's newest It Boy believable. He also shows a lighter side early on, coupled with a deadly confidence that made his initial decision a disastrous one. One sympathizes whenever his face starts collapsing. One recoils at his unrequited and imagined love towards Dr. Carr. 

One is also horrified at some of his actions. Harries' performance and characterization allows us to be understanding that Matt's actions were prompted by a cruel twist of fate. We also, however, can be appalled at said actions. This is especially true at the end, when Matt seems dead set on having a romantic relationship with Caitlyn despite her loyalty to John and never showing any romantic feelings for Matt. There is enough to suggestion that not all is what it appears to be when Matt and Caitlyn see each other for the last time. The end result is both sad and necessary.

Naomi Ackie is equally strong as Dr. Caitlyn Carr. Ackie makes Carr into an intelligent and capable figure who is methodical in her methods. A particularly effective moment is when she is studying Matt's sleeping to see how his stress levels affect his physical transformations. Carr is shocked to see Matt transform into his enemies but is more shocked to see him transform into her. This is an effective jump scare that also shows Carr's distress at how things are going for Matt. She is, to be fair, not as strong when it comes to romantic scenes with Max Minghella. Minghella himself was not that strong as John Borelli. He seemed a bit too casual and trying a bit hard to be a tough cop. It is serviceable but not great.

What is great is the body horror elements in Clayface. The film does not shrink from moments of terror in Matt's physical disintegration. Of particular note is when he is on a plane that hit turbulence. Matt is desperately attempts to literally pull himself together while a stewardess attempts to get him back to his seat. In between jolts, Matt has to start cutting to reshape his face. The audience sees how his figure starts reshaping, potentially with gruesome results. A certain killing is quite shocking, but I did not find it graphic. Curiously, I found that particular killing sad albeit understandable. Clayface does not hold back from Matt's body reshaping into sometimes horrifying manners. It shows that large budgets do not necessarily result in better results. For what was spent on the film, Clayface works very well. Running a bit over an hour and a half, Clayface never wears out its welcome.

I think Volker Bertelmann's score works well with the story. I think also that Rod Hardy's cinematography does mostly well, though sometimes I did think it was too dark or overtly hazy.

Overall, I found Clayface to be an effective and entertaining film. Clayface blends body horror with an origin story to a surprisingly sympathetic villain. Strong performances, an engaging story and enough of a fright element all make Clayface into a rare thing: a good comic book adaptation. 

No comments:

Post a Comment

Views are always welcome, but I would ask that no vulgarity be used. Any posts that contain foul language or are bigoted in any way will not be posted.
Thank you.