Dead of Winter (2025): A Review (Review #2185)

DEAD OF WINTER (2025)

When I first saw Dead of Winter, I thought that it might have made for a good short film but not that great for a feature film. Upon a second viewing, I think Dead of Winter makes for a good feature film. Strong performances and a smoothly flowing story make Dead of Winter a well-crafted film that is better than I initially remembered. 

Barb Lunquist (Emma Thompson) is driving to a remote Minnesota lake. It is winter here, but Barb has a mission that reveals itself in a series of flashbacks. A quick blizzard gets her a bit lost. The memories of her long love affair with Karl also distract her.

Barb comes upon a remote cabin and is concerned with some blood that she sees in the snow. The remote mountain man in the Camo Jacket (Marc Menchaca) quickly tells her where the lake she's looking for is and tells her that the blood is from an animal. Barb might not be convinced but won't get further involved. 

Things take a sudden turn when Barb does arrive at the frozen lake and begins ice fishing. She struggles with her memories of Karl. Even in her grief, however, she cannot ignore how Camo Jacket is chasing after a young girl whose arms are tied. Camo Jacket, oblivious to everything save this girl, doesn't see that he was watched. Barb now has to do something. 

Barb now finds this hostage at Camo Jacket's cabin. She assures the young girl that she will not abandon her but will get help. She also sees Purple Lady (Judy Greer), the brains behind the kidnapping. It becomes a cat-and-mouse game between Barb and Purple Lady/Camo Jacket (the former wearing a large purple parka). Each gets the upper hand from time to time, but time is running out for all concerned.

Why is the young girl named Leah (Laurel Marsden) being held prisoner? Purple Lady plans to harvest Leah's liver to save her own life. Others both directly and not directly involved in Purple Lady's deranged scheme will not live to tell their tale. The battle to save Leah will culminate at that frozen lake. Here, the Widow Lundquist will fulfill her late husband's final wish with his ashes, but who will live and who will die?

After initially seeing Dead of Winter with my family as a "mystery movie", our consensus was that it was not very good. After seeing it a second time, I thought better of the film. I think we were displeased with the dour nature and bleak ending. Dead of Winter is still a downer of a film. It also has those flashbacks between the young Barb Sorensen (Gaia Wise) and young Karl Lunquist (Cuan Hosty-Blaney) pop in more times than I think necessary. 

That being said, I appreciated more in Dead of Winter than the first time that I saw it. At the top of that list is Emma Thompson's performance. On both a technical and emotional level, Thompson does very well in the role of Barb. She maintains a solid American Midwest accent that would not be out of place in Fargo. She makes Barb into the embodiment of "Minnesota nice", with her not even cursing beyond a "heck" or "darn". I think that maybe she did use foul language once, but that was probably the extend of her vocal vulgarity.

Her performance works well throughout. She can express Barb's loss and emotional despair with just a glance. She can also show strength and common sense when having to comfort Leah or face off against Purple Lady. She even blends both when dealing with Camo Jacket, whom we discover is Purple Lady's henpecked husband.

Judy Greer is also quite strong as Purple Lady. She is villainous. However, we also see Purple Lady's desperation in doing all that she can to survive. Marc Menchaca is in turns frightening and sympathetic as Camo Jacket. He is as he says he is, which is not a bad man. He is just a very weak man. Laurel Marsden does well as the frightened Leah, desperate to live despite her own past troubles.

Credit should be given to director Brian Kirk for guiding his actors to strong performances. He also kept things flowing mostly well given that Dead of Winter is only 98 minutes long. Nicholas Jacobson-Larson and Dalton Leeb's screenplay also gives us a good deal of the various characters' backstories without it being forced. Again, I could argue that Barb's flashbacks do pop up a bit more than necessary. Still, that Dead of Winter did not slip into farce is a credit to everyone involved.

I think that Dead of Winter is a good albeit downbeat film. It is in some ways as sparse as the Minnesota winter it is set in. That downbeat manner might put some people off. It did my family when we first saw it. Overall, though, I think Dead of Winter is a strong but bleak film that should be given a chance. 

DECISION: B+