Sunday, March 4, 2012

Wounds of War

HELL AND BACK AGAIN

Whatever one may think of the conflicts in Iraq and Afghanistan, one who is not doing the fighting and dying can only support or oppose them thanks to those who are actually there.  The battles the soldiers face on the front is one thing, but those they face when they return can be equally hard.  Contrary to the popular image, I think veterans return home relatively intact given what they had to do.  In short, I don't think the majority of veterans are mentally unstable and one rude remark from "going postal".  However, this isn't to say there aren't psychological injuries that can go along with any physical injuries acquired in the theater of war.  Hell and Back Again allows us into the lives of a combat veteran and his spouse, attempting to put their lives into a semblance of what it was before...

Director Danfung Dennis follows Sergeant Nathan Harris of Echo Company Second Platoon both in war and peace.  We're told that shortly before he is to return to America he was hit and was seriously wounded.  Once home, Sgt. Harris and his wife Ashley go through their lives as well as they can: their lives revolving around medical appointments and medication fro Sgt. Harris.  He, however, not only has the physical injuries (he is unable to walk without assistance of some kind), but he also deals with his mental health.

In between seeing how Sgt. and Mrs. Harris try to deal with his injuries, Hell and Back Again intercut scenes of his time in Afghanistan, both in the midst of the fighting and of him and his troops dealing with the Afghan people.  The battle scenes appear to be a mirror to Harris' internal and external struggles to put his life together the best way he can.

At times, one becomes alarmed with Harris' behavior.  He appears to love his guns way too much: at one point pointing it towards himself, another when he makes a show of being quick on the draw.  However, seeing the physical agony he is undergoing (as well as how his injuries are keeping him from returning to the front) give us the viewer a sense of frustration at our own powerlessness.

However, we also get a sense of hope with the Harrises.  At one point in Hell and Back Again, as Sgt. Harris dresses for another appointment, we hear him in voiceover talking about how when he first joined at 18 he basically did it to 'kill people'.  Now, after having gone through the scourge of war, seeing it up-close, and living to tell the tale, he has at 26 reached a more mature view on war.  It isn't just about killing, it isn't a live-action version of a video game (which in the film he continues to enjoy playing), but it is about leaving something better behind.

We see this when we see him and the other troops in Afghanistan.  The soldiers appear to be genuinely interested in making life better for the Afghan civilian population (at one point, Harris himself reflects on how we went into Afghanistan to do good), and the troops also are shown to be doing their duty and being professional about it (although one of them does express frustration to an Afghan about how the villager appears to be lying about information about the Taliban in the area). 

There is also a scene where we go to a memorial service for those in the company who have fallen.  The chaplain himself becomes highly emotional, and it is hard not to react emotionally at seeing how the military honors those who have, in the words of President Lincoln, given the last full measure of devotion.  To the bagpipes rendition of Amazing Grace, to see the photos of so many young men, much younger than most of the viewers (most certainly younger than I), is a moving and heartbreaking scene.  It has us contemplate just how many lives, in their early stages, have been lost to the inhumanity, cruelty, and compulsion to the darker forces of man's nature. 

One scene in Hell and Back Again sets things so well.  Sgt. Harris, in his motorized cart, enters a Wal-Mart where we meet the traditional greeter.  She is a senior citizen, who is also incapacitated and in a motorized vehicle herself.  Here we see two people who need machines to help them move around: one due to war, one due to age.  While Dennis doesn't focus on the curious imagery of a young man and an old woman in similar circumstances, we can't help think on how life can grant out different ends to people.

The war footage is shot so well it really comes as close to a 'you-are-there' style as those of us who will probably never see war ourselves will come.  Dennis also manages to never shortchange the war footage with that of the homefront, nor does it appear to be gratuitous or distracting.  Both his struggles to stay alive in Afghanistan and in the United States are blended remarkably well.

A minor flaw is that we really don't see much or hear much from Ashley Harris.  Those who live with veterans have their own burdens, and while the focus is understandably on Sgt. Harris, one thinks that Mrs. Harris' views or her own difficulties of being in this situation could have been given more time.  Another time, one of the doctors was audibly difficult to understand.  Whether he sounded as if he were speaking underwater because of Dennis' overall vision for Hell and Back Again or a technical issue I cannot say, but I found that a minor distraction. 

I know people who opposed the Iraq Intervention, who served in Iraq, and those who fully support the action.  The same goes for the Afghan campaign.  Hell and Back Again doesn't touch on the rightness or wrongness of the military campaigns.  This is a good thing, because the focus should be on those who fought there, who died there, and who came back from there.  The position of the viewer is irrelevant so far as that Hell and Back Again is neither a pro or anti-Afghan Intervention documentary.  It doesn't go into what the Taliban did or what the American-led troops did or did not do.

Instead, Hell and Back Again is about those who will be in one way or another fighting long after the fighting is relegated to the history books.  It is about the men (and women) who lived it and lived through it, and the women (and men) they came back to.  It is about shattered people: some shattered physically, some mentally, some both, and those who survived.    
DECISION: B+

No comments:

Post a Comment

Views are always welcome, but I would ask that no vulgarity be used. Any posts that contain foul language or are bigoted in any way will not be posted.
Thank you.